1. 1798
Col. William Cobrath appointed as the first Sheriff of Oneida County.
2. 1799
Sheriff Elizur Mosley
3. 1800 to 1802
Sheriff Charles C. Broadhead appointed to office by the Governor and served under the amended State Constitution to a three-year term.
4. 1803 to 1806
Sheriff James S. Kipp
5. 1807
Sheriff Benajah Merrrill
6. 1808 to 1809
Sheriff James S. Kipp
7. 1810
Sheriff Benajah Merrrill
8. 1811 to 1814
Sheriff James S. Kipp
9. 1815 to 1819
Sheriff Apollos Cooper Under Sheriff John B. Pease
10. 1819 to 1820
Sheriff John B. Pease
11. 1821 to 1825
Sheriff John E. Hinman became the first elected Sheriff of Oneida County in 1822.
12. 1826 to 1828
Sheriff David Pierson
13. 1829 to 1831
Sheriff John E. Hinman
14. 1832 to 1834
Sheriff Samuel M. Mott
15. 1835 to 1837
Sheriff Erastus Willard
16. 1838 to 1840
Sheriff Lyman Curtis
17. 1841
Sheriff David Moulton
18. 1842
Sheriff Theodore S. Faxton
19. 1843
Sheriff Israel S. Parker | Under Sheriff Edward Eames
20. 1844 to 1846
Sheriff Palmer V. Kellogg | Under Sheriff John S. Ray
21. 1847 to 1849
Sheriff Lester Baker | Under Sheriff Edward Eames
22. 1850 to 1852
Sheriff John R. Jones | Under Sheriff Henry B. Ostrom
23. 1853 to 1855
Sheriff Hugh Crocker | Under Sheriff Hubbard C. Pond
24. 1856 to 1858
Sheriff Calvin Hall | Under Sheriff L.S. Wood
25. 1859 to 1861
Sheriff William J. McKown | Under Sheriff John S. Ray
26. 1862 to 1863
Sheriff Hugh Crocker | Under Sheriff John S. Ray
27. 1864 to 1866
Sheriff D.B. Danforth | Under Sheriff James C. Donaldson
28. 1867 to 1869
Sheriff George F. Weaver | Under Sheriff James C. Donaldson
29. 1870 to 1873
Sheriff Lewis Gaylord | Under Sheriff James C. Donaldson | Under Sheriff Glen Petrie
30. 1874 to 1876
Sheriff George Benedict | Under Sheriff Glen Petrie
31. 1877 to 1879
Sheriff Frederick G. Weaver (Son of former Sheriff, George F. Weaver) | Under Sheriff Van Rensselear Weaver
32. 1880 to 1882
Sheriff Francis X. Meyers Under Sheriff George W. Roberts | Under Sheriff F.X. Meyers Jr.
33. 1883 to 1885
Sheriff Thomas D. Penfield | Under Sheriff I. Stoddard Penfield
34. 1886 to 1888
Sheriff John Batchelor | Under Sheriff Fred Batchelor
35. 1889 to 1891
Sheriff Thomas Wheeler | Under Sheriff John Batchelor
36. 1892 to 1894
Sheriff John C. Schreiber | Under Sheriff John C. Fulmer
37. 1895 to 1897
Sheriff Van Rensselaer Weaver | Under Sheriff William G. Reese
38. 1898 to 1900
Sheriff William H. Reese | Under Sheriff Patrick F. Foley
39. 1901 to 1903
Sheriff Lincoln D. Brownell | Under Sheriff Patrick F. Foley
40. 1904 to 1906
Sheriff Samuel H. Jones | Under Sheriff Leonard Drake
41. 1907 to 1909
Sheriff Frederick Gillmore | Under Sheriff Leonard Drake | Under Sheriff Joseph Hamlin
42. 1910 to 1912
Sheriff Daniel P. Becker | Under Sheriff Harry J. Moss
43. 1913 to 1914
Sheriff William T. Donnelly | Under Sheriff Edward E. Donohue
44. 1915
Sheriff Harry Moss | Under Sheriff Charles H.F. Agne
45. 1916
Sheriff William K. Harvey | Under Sheriff Charles H.F. Agne
46. 1917 to 1919
Sheriff Herbert L. Sweet | Under Sheriff William J. Jones
47. 1920 to 1922
Sheriff Arthur W. Pickard | Under Sheriff Harold L. Clarke
48. 1923 to 1925
Sheriff Frederick L. Meiss | Under Sheriff William J. Jones
49. 1926 to 1928
Sheriff John G. Thomas | Under Sheriff William J. Jones
50. 1929 to 1931
Sheriff Richard W. Thomas | Under Sheriff Fred W. Clark
51. 1932 to 1934
Sheriff Albert E. Ellinger | Under Sheriff William A. McElhinney
52. 1935 to 1936
Sheriff Chauncey J. Williams | Under Sheriff Herbert L. Sweet
53. 1937 to 1942
Sheriff J. Bradbury German Jr. | Under Sheriff Herbert L. Sweet | Under Sheriff Fred L. Meiss
54. 1943 to 1950
Sheriff Wm. R. Williams | Under Sheriff Fred L. Meiss | Under Sheriff Chas T. Williams
55. 1951 to 1959
Sheriff Charles T. Baker | Under Sheriff Chas T. Williams | Under Sheriff Harry Scott
56. 1960 to 1967
Sheriff Archie G. Eastman | Under Sheriff Robert W. Ingalls
57. 1968to 1973
Sheriff Joseph A. Piccola | Under Sheriff William Hasenauer
58. 1973 to 1990
Sheriff William A. Hasenauer | Under Sheriff Stanley Kolasz (First Sheriff to serve 4-year terms) | Under Sheriff Ross F. Simeral | Under Sheriff Robert W. Ingalls II
59. 1991 to 1994
Sheriff Gerald F. Washburn | Under Sheriff Pasquale D. Lagatta | Lt. John Allen (Acting Under Sheriff)
60. 1995 to 2010
Sheriff Daniel G. Middaugh |. Under Sheriff M. Peter Paravati
61. 2011 to Current
Sheriff Robert M. Maciol | Under Sheriff Robert S. Swenszkowski | Under Sheriff Joseph A. Lisi
